Department stores need to stop acting as gatekeepers for emerging Australian designers and start operating as platforms for them, according to RMIT University associate professor Carol Tan.
Her comments come as David Jones faces a tough FY27 amid fears it will enter voluntary administration this week. That comes as it reviews its store network while major concession operators scale back across its floors. Country Road Group plans to cut nearly 100 of its more than 280 concessions across David Jones from early 2027, covering Country Road, Witchery, Mimco, Trenery and Politix.
Accent Group stopped supplying the department store in July. Labels including Acler, Effie Kats, Significant Other and Aston Studio have moved to exclusive arrangements with Myer.
And David Jones is just one of many examples globally of department stores facing a tough new consumer market. Saks in the United States collapsed in bankruptcy earlier this year before relaunching under a new operating model and structure, while Debenhams in the United Kingdom exited its entire store fleet after collapsing into liquidation in 2020.
Tan, program manager of RMIT’s Master of Fashion (Entrepreneurship), said department stores remained valuable for emerging labels but no longer controlled their path to customers.
“Today, social media, eCommerce and direct-to-consumer channels mean that emerging brands no longer need department stores to reach consumers. Many successful brands are building strong audiences independently,” she said.
“However, I think department stores continue to play an important role in discovery.”
In recent years, David Jones has presented the National Designer Award for the Australian Fashion Festival (formerly Melbourne Fashion Festival), and has run showroom and runway events for designers.
Tan said shoppers still wanted to touch and try products before buying, particularly in fashion, where fabrication, fit and quality were hard to judge online. For emerging brands, she said, the cost of physical retail remained the biggest hurdle.
“Taking on a lease in a major shopping centre, even for a short-term activation, can be prohibitively expensive,” she said.
Rather than relying solely on traditional wholesale, Tan said department stores could host four- to six-week pop-ups, brand residencies, founder events, styling workshops and product demonstrations. She said these spaces could showcase emerging Australian designers, sustainable labels and Indigenous fashion businesses, giving shoppers new reasons to visit.
“In this sense, I think the role of the department store is shifting from being a gatekeeper to being a platform. The most successful department stores will be those that help customers discover what is next, rather than simply sell what is already established,” she said.
Tan pointed to international department stores that have stayed relevant by giving shoppers reasons to visit beyond product. She cited Nordstrom’s reputation for customer service and convenience. She also cited Selfridges’ events, sustainability initiatives and cultural programming. In Japan and South Korea, she noted, department stores have combined retail with food halls, beauty services, dining and entertainment.
“What these retailers understand is that consumers can buy products almost anywhere. Their role extends beyond selling products,” she said.
“In many cases, customers visit because they want the overall experience, not simply because they need a product.”
Many of those operators run lean networks relative to their markets. Selfridges trades from four UK stores: its Oxford Street flagship, two in Manchester and one in Birmingham. It returned to profit in its latest financial year, with stores driving performance while online sales declined.
Nordstrom ended its last publicly reported financial year with 92 full-line stores across the US. It has since closed full-line sites in Dallas and Delaware while expanding its off-price Nordstrom Rack banner.
In South Korea, Shinsegae operates around a dozen department stores, and its Gangnam store was the first in the country to pass three trillion won in annual sales. Or about $3.2 billion in AUD.
By comparison, David Jones operates 38 stores across Australia and New Zealand, and Myer runs around 55 department stores. This is both in a market that is 12 times smaller in population compared to the US, and 2.5 times the size of the UK population.
Owner Anchorage Capital Partners has noted that David Jones is reviewing its store network, while media reports suggest the chain could shrink to between 12 and 20 locations.
In FY25, David Jones reported an 8.7 per cent slip in total sales to $2 billion, while Myer saw a total sales lift of 1.2 per cent to $3.3 billion when excluding the acquired Apparel Brands from Premier Investments but including David Lawrence, Marcs and Sass & Bide.
Tan said a smaller footprint need not be a weakness.
“In some cases, a smaller and more productive store network can actually strengthen a retailer. The key is ensuring that the remaining stores provide a consistent and compelling customer experience,” she said.
"Consumers should know what to expect whether they are shopping in Melbourne, Sydney, Brisbane or Perth. Retailers invest heavily in their brands, and that brand promise should be reflected consistently across the network."
Tan also said the growing use of concessions had narrowed the advice available on the shop floor. Sales staff employed by individual brands often know their own products well but can only advise on those lines. She isn't suggesting department stores move away from concessions. Instead, she argued they should be complemented with service that spans the whole store.
“Ideally, a department store team member should be able to curate a solution for that customer, perhaps recommending a jacket from one brand, shoes from another and accessories from a third,” she said.
For brands currently wholesaling or on concession, Tan said the first priority was understanding their exposure. That means reviewing payment terms, inventory commitments, future orders and receivables, and having alternative routes to market ready.
“Department stores remain important partners, particularly for customer acquisition and visibility, but the strongest brands tend to have multiple routes to market,” she said.
